Is Medicare Good Insurance? Evaluating Your Coverage Options

by David Bynon, last updated

So, you’re turning 65 – congrats. Or maybe you’re just starting to think about Medicare because you’re approaching retirement age. One of the first questions that probably comes to mind is, “Is Medicare good insurance?”

It’s a big question; the answer isn’t a simple yes or no. Let’s unravel the mystery and equip you to answer that very important question confidently.

A 65-year-old couple sits with their Medicare insurance agent and asks, "Is Medicare good insurance?"

Is Medicare Good Insurance? Breaking It Down

To get started, it’s helpful to know what Medicare covers.

Understanding Medicare: The Basics

Medicare has different “Parts,” which are like puzzle pieces. Each part covers certain healthcare costs, such as drug plans. Understanding the coverage Medicare offers can give you insight into whether or not it will be good insurance for you.

Medicare Part Coverage
Part A (Hospital Insurance) Helps cover inpatient care in hospitals, skilled nursing facility care, and some home health care and hospice care.
Part B (Medical Insurance) Helps cover services from doctors and other healthcare providers, outpatient care, home health care, durable medical equipment, and preventive services.
Part C (Medicare Advantage Health Plans) A private healthcare option that replaces Part A and Part B benefits and may add additional coverage.
Part D (Medicare Prescription Drug Coverage) Helps cover the cost of prescription drugs. You get Part D through private insurance companies approved by Medicare.

Knowing which part covers what is important, but you’ve got choices on how to get your Medicare coverage:

Original Medicare

Think of Original Medicare (Part A and Part B) as the standard, government-run plan. It’s what most people automatically qualify for. While Original Medicare offers decent coverage, it doesn’t cover everything.

That’s where you’ll need to think about supplemental coverage like Medigap, which helps fill those coverage “gaps”. Medigap is Medicare Supplement Insurance that helps pay for some healthcare costs that Original Medicare doesn’t cover. This can be confusing, but don’t worry; we’ll explore supplemental options further.

Medicare Advantage (Part C)

Medicare Advantage, sometimes called Part C, is offered through private insurance companies. These choices kick in because each insurance company combines its version of a Medicare Advantage plan. These plans, which often function as an alternative to Original Medicare, vary in cost, coverage, and extras.

Some Advantage plans might offer extra benefits not covered by Original Medicare, such as vision or dental. However, is Medicare good insurance when using these private companies? Well, there’s usually a catch. Medicare Advantage often comes with network limitations. So, that means your choice of doctors and hospitals might be restricted, a trade-off you’ll want to consider.

Weighing the Pros and Cons

If you’re thinking, “Is Medicare good insurance,” look at the pluses and minuses before jumping in.

The Upside

The benefits of Medicare help answer “Is Medicare good insurance?”

Accessibility

Once you hit that magic age of 65, you’re generally eligible for Medicare, no matter your health history – preexisting conditions and all.

Cost-Effectiveness (Mostly)

You’ve been paying those Medicare taxes all the years you worked, so there’s a bit of satisfaction knowing you’ve got something to show for it, right? Many folks can access Part A without monthly premiums, which softens the blow to your retirement budget. Plus, the costs for Part B and Part D are pretty reasonable, especially when comparing those costs to private insurance premiums – especially now.

While you still need to pay deductibles and copays (the joys of healthcare.), most agree that Medicare’s pricing is generally easier on the wallet. In 2023 the average employee’s payroll-deducted premium cost for employer-sponsored health insurance was $1,401, or about $117 per month.

That may not seem bad. However, that number reflects what an employee pays – imagine paying the entire premium yourself.

Coverage That Counts

Okay, no single insurance plan will shower you with unicorns and rainbows, but let’s get real – Medicare is there for the stuff that matters: think hospital stays, doctor visits, essential medical equipment. Plus, there’s that extra safety net knowing those costs are covered across the U.S. That’s a serious plus, especially if you’re the adventurous type who might be thinking of that retirement relocation.

The Flip Side

Medicare has some potential downsides. Is Medicare good insurance despite these?

Not-So-Free

Hold on – even if Part A is premium-free for many, don’t go cashing in those retirement savings just yet. Medicare has the Part B premium, which costs about $165 a month (with the cost deducted from your Social Security check). If you sign up for Part D, you’ll face another monthly premium, about $43 per month on average.

Gaps in Coverage (Those Pesky Extras)

Here’s the kicker: “Is Medicare good insurance?” It might be good, but it doesn’t cover everything. If you’re a big fan of trips to the dentist, you might be surprised to hear that original Medicare doesn’t typically foot the bill for routine dental care or snazzy new dentures.

Eye exams, most dental care, and those yearly physical check-ups – yeah, original Medicare generally gives those a big thumbs down. Medicare beneficiaries may need to explore options such as a Medicare Advantage plan with dental services for those services.

Surprise Bills and Out-of-Pocket Surprises

Nobody enjoys unexpected bills, but the question of “Is Medicare good insurance?” always depends on costs. Original Medicare sometimes requires folks to shoulder a hefty 20% of their medical expenses through deductibles, co-payments, and coinsurance—also known as out-of-pocket costs. If your healthcare costs go through the roof, you’ll pay more out of pocket.

For peace of mind, that’s why you often hear about people looking into additional coverage, like a Medicare supplement. Purchasing a Medicare supplement can provide peace of mind for those concerned about high out-of-pocket costs.

Supplemental Coverage: Bridging the Gaps

So, how can you address the whole “gaps in coverage” thing to make Medicare REALLY good insurance? Well, you’ve got options.

Medicare Advantage Plans

Medicare Advantage plans try to compensate for some of the things Original Medicare leaves out—think of them as Medicare with some extra sprinkles on top. Often, these plans include Medicare drug coverage and combine hospital and medical coverage (Parts A and B) and even sometimes drug coverage (Part D).

Plus, you’ll discover they frequently cover perks that Original Medicare doesn’t, like routine vision and dental care. And this is great – if those services are important to you, opting for a Medicare Advantage plan might be your winning ticket. Is Medicare good insurance when going the Medicare Advantage Route?

Medicare Advantage Plans – The Catch

One word of warning – the price of those perks often comes in the form of network restrictions. You’ll need to ensure doctors and hospitals are part of your plan’s network, which could mean saying “sayonara” to seeing your long-time physician.

Medigap (Medicare Supplement Insurance)

Here’s another contender: Medigap policies, those trusty sidekicks designed to step in and help cover costs that Original Medicare misses. That means chipping in for those dreaded copayments, coinsurance, and deductibles, helping to keep those unexpected expenses from giving your retirement savings a heart attack.

Of course, like any worthwhile sidekick, they don’t come free. Expect to pay a monthly premium, which can vary based on what the plan covers and who offers it. However, many consider the investment well worth it, giving them the best chance to achieve their goal of sailing into those sunset years stress-free.

Making Medicare Work for YOU

So is Medicare good insurance for YOU? Like most things, the answer depends. Do you travel a lot and value freedom of choice in healthcare providers?

Sticking with Original Medicare and considering a Medigap policy to cover those pesky gaps might be your jam. Is having affordable coverage but being restricted to network providers OK with you? Medicare Advantage might just be your golden ticket to healthcare peace of mind.

Expert Advice For Your Decision

You’re not alone. “Start researching your options several months before you first sign up for Medicare or before your open enrollment period,” says Julie Carter at the Medicare Rights Center. There’s a lot of information out there.

There are even enrollment deadlines to keep track of – you’ll find specific Medicare enrollment periods each year, generally running from October 15th to December 7th. It can be confusing. If you don’t enroll when you’re first eligible, you might get stuck with late enrollment penalties – no bueno.

Conclusion

The bottom line – “Is Medicare good insurance?” It sure can be – if you choose the best plan to suit your needs, understand what is covered, and proactively bridge the gap with a supplemental plan. So, congratulations on entering this exciting new chapter, armed with the information to navigate the ins and outs of Medicare.

FAQs about is Medicare good insurance

What are the disadvantages of having Medicare?

While Medicare offers many benefits, it does come with its drawbacks: It doesn’t cover all medical expenses, potentially leaving you with out-of-pocket costs. It may not cover routine dental, vision, or hearing care services. Finding a plan can be confusing. And coverage for care while traveling outside the US is limited.

What is the biggest problem with Medicare?

The most common gripe folks have is probably the out-of-pocket costs. While Medicare helps, it doesn’t cover 100% of costs. Depending on the specific coverage, you’ll be on the line for deductibles, copayments, and coinsurance, which, for those who need extensive medical care, could rack up quickly. And nobody wants to be hit with medical bills they can’t afford, particularly in their golden years, right?

Is it better to have Medicare or private insurance?

This question doesn’t have a cut-and-dry answer. Really. If you’re approaching retirement age, most find Medicare a good option for coverage and peace of mind. Private insurance companies determine their costs differently – typically through health status, medical history, and claims history.

This type of pricing system isn’t for everyone. If you have employer-sponsored health insurance that you love and have the option to keep it into retirement, that would be great. The most important thing to do is your research to determine the best, most cost-effective coverage that suits YOUR personal needs.

Is Medicare enough for health insurance?

Well, that is entirely dependent on YOU. Factors such as your current health status, any anticipated future medical needs, and your tolerance for financial risk will come into play here. Many folks are completely satisfied with just original Medicare. However, to make it truly “enough” or better, you might find that pairing Original Medicare with a Medigap policy or carefully selecting a Medicare Advantage plan that fits your lifestyle is the route for you.

Was this article helpful?

Related Articles