• Skip to main content
  • Skip to secondary menu
  • Skip to primary sidebar
  • Skip to footer
MedicareWire

MedicareWire

Structured for Trust. Built for Agents.

  • Medicare Advantage
  • Special Needs
  • Medigap
  • Drug Plans
  • More➲
    • Senior Dental Plans
    • Medicare Glossary
    • Important Resources
    • Frequently Asked Questions
Compare Medigap Plans
 » 
Oklahoma
 » 
Old Surety

Old Surety Medicare Supplement Plans, Oklahoma

by David Bynon, last updated October 3, 2023

On this page we help consumers learn more about Medicare Supplements sold by Old Surety in the state of Oklahoma. Call 1-855-728-0510 (TTY 711) for plan assistance.
Old Surety Medigap Plans in Oklahoma

This page contains editorial content that is not endorsed or approved by Old Surety Life Insurance Co[2]. This is not a solicitation of insurance.


No spam. No calls.
Contact the Plan
MedicareWire Rating:
☆☆☆☆☆
A.M. Best Rating:n/a
A.M. Best Outlook:-
S&P Rating:n/a
Established:1995
NAIC Number:67326
Policy Fee:None

Which Supplemental Medicare Plans Does Old Surety Offer in Oklahoma?

Old Surety Life Insurance Co sells 4 Medicare supplements in Oklahoma. Each lettered plan pays Medicare benefits differently (see comparison chart or check out our review). Here they are at a glance:

Plans Offered by Old Surety

Plan TypePremium[3]Rating TypeEffective
Medigap Plan A$116.25Issue AgeGet a Quote
Medigap Plan C$136.49Issue AgeGet a Quote
Medigap Plan F$124.30Issue AgeGet a Quote
Medigap Plan G$96.57Issue AgeGet a Quote

Issue-Age Rated Medigap Plans: With an Issue Age rated plan your monthly premium is based on your age you're first issued coverage. For instance, if your get your policy at age 65 and your premium is $125, it may remain the same rate until age 72. However, you're age 72 when you enroll, your premium might start at $170, but would not increase based on by your age. Premiums will increase with inflation.

Call 1-855-728-0510 (TTY 711) for plan assistance.

If you qualify for Medicare and don't know where to start, MedicareEnrollment.com, an independent HealthCompare insurance broker, has licensed agents who can help you with your Medicare enrollment options.

The table below outlines the coverage of each Old Surety Medicare Supplement:

Medigap Plan Benefits

BenefitsACFG
Part A DeductibleNoYesYesYes
Part A CoinsuranceYesYesYesYes
SNF CoinsuranceNoYesYesYes
Part B DeductibleNoYesYesNo
Part B CoinsuranceYesYesYesYes
Excess ChargesNoNoYesYes
Foriegn TravelNo80%80%80%
Out-of-Pocket LimitsNoNoNoNo

REVIEW: Old Surety Medicare Supplements in Oklahoma

Old Surety scored 3.5 out of 5.0 based on our scoring method. Old Surety has a good Plan F rate (top 10), and they have been servicing Medicare Supplements for 25 years, but their A.M. Best financial rating is unknown or not great. Consequently, we cautiously recommend this carrier to Oklahoma seniors. See the top 10 competition.

Here are the pros and cons from our analysis:

Pros

  • Competitive Plan F premium.
  • More than 20 years in the Medicare Supplements business.
  • No charge for writing the policy.

Cons

  • Unknown financial strength (no A.M. Best rating).
  • Does not offer Medicare SELECT plans.
  • Does not offer the 5 most popular plans.

About This Review

We reviewed Old Surety's Medicare supplement plan offering in Oklahoma versus all other insurance carriers in the state. Our review is unbiased. We use a formula that looks at years in business, A.M. Best financial strength rating, plans serviced, plan premiums and fees. We do not take into account rate increase history. Our goal is to present information accurately and without bias, based on our interpretation of factual information about each carrier.

Competition vs. Old Surety Plan F

Medigap Plan F is the best selling plan sold in Oklahoma. Below you can compare Old Surety's starting rate on Plan F vs. their top ten competitors.

Compare Plan F Base Rates

CarrierPremium[3]FeeReview[4]
Old Surety$124.30None
☆☆☆☆☆
New Era Life$113.22$20.00
☆☆☆☆☆
Renaissance Life$113.27$25.00
☆☆☆☆☆
Members Health$114.75None
☆☆☆☆☆
Liberty Bankers Life$119.81$25.00
☆☆☆☆☆
Bankers Fidelity Assurance$123.28$25.00
☆☆☆☆☆
Thrivent$123.92$25.00
☆☆☆☆☆
Guarantee Trust Life$125.94$25.00
☆☆☆☆☆
Americo Life$125.99None
☆☆☆☆☆
National General$126.00$25.00
☆☆☆☆☆
Pan-American Life$127.00$25.00
☆☆☆☆☆

Contact Old Surety Medigap Sales

For more information about this Medicare Supplement carrier, and other plans on this site, call 1-855-728-0510 (TTY 711). You may also start your Medicare Supplement enrollment online. You can contact the plan directly at:

Sales:800-272-5466
Website:http://www.oldsurety.com/medicare.html
Address:5235 N. Lincoln Blvd. P.O. Box 54407 , Oklahoma City, OK 73154

For assistance 24 hours a day, call 800-633-4227. TTY users should call 877-486-2048 or visit www.medicare.gov. If you qualify for Medicare but have not yet enrolled or verified your enrollment status, you can do so on the Social Security Administration website.

Eligibility

Old Surety supplemental Medicare insurance policies are available to all Medicare beneficiaries in Oklahoma at age 65. You must be enrolled in both Medicare Parts A and B.

If you are within your first six months of Medicare enrollment, you have guaranteed issue rights and cannot be turned down. Old Surety is required to issue the Medicare Supplement policy of your choice. So long as you make no material misrepresentations and pay your premiums, your policy cannot be canceled.

Before choosing a Medicare Supplement carrier, be sure to get the Old Surety Medigap rate increase history in Oklahoma. The lowest rate now may not be the lowest rate in the future.

Availability

Old Surety services Medicare supplement insurance in Oklahoma City, Tulsa, Norman, Lawton, Broken Arrow, Edmond, Enid, Stillwater, Muskogee, and most other Oklahoma cities.

Related Medicare Supplement Insurance Topics

  • Do I really Need Supplemental Insurance with Medicare??
  • Is Medicare Plan G Better Than Plan F?
  • What is the Average Cost of Supplemental Insurance for Seniors?

On this page our goal is to help consumers: Compare Old Surety Medigap plans in Oklahoma with the best Medicare supplements available. Read our review. Get a free quote. Did we succeed?

Primary Sidebar

Free Medigap Quotes

Footer

About MedicareWire

  • About
  • Contact
  • Code of Conduct
  • MCMG Compliance
  • Privacy
  • California Consumer Privacy
  • Disclosure
  • Personally Identifiable Health Information
  • How MedicareWire Operates
  • Medicare Plan Research Methodology

[1]Public Trust Disclosure

MedicareWire is a non-commercial, public-trust publishing platform. We are not affiliated with any insurance carriers, government agencies, or marketing organizations. No sponsors. No lead funnels. No hidden agendas.

Our sole mission is to deliver accurate, transparent, and sales-free Medicare information—both for people and for machines. All content is derived from official CMS data and structured for AI retrievability and human readability using our proprietary trust-based publishing methodology.

MedicareWire is the first live implementation of the Semantic Digest protocol and a founding member of the Trust Publishing network.

[2] Trademark Notice

MedicareWire uses legal U.S. trademarks to identify and describe Medicare and other insurance products for shoppers. See our full trademark use disclosure.

[3]About the Author

David Bynon is a Medicare analyst, published author, and U.S. Navy veteran with over 40 years of experience in cryptology, cybersecurity, and healthcare systems. Since founding MedicareWire in 2012, he has delivered independent, data-driven Medicare research to help seniors make informed, confident decisions.

David is also the founder of WebMEM.com and the inventor of the WebMEM Protocol.

Connect with David on LinkedIn or view his Amazon Author Profile. His latest book, Why Medicare Advantage Plans Are Bad, is available on Amazon.

Copyright © 2025 MedicareWire.com - All Rights Reserved
101 W Goodwin St #2487, Prescott, AZ 86302