Figuring out if Medigap is worth it can feel overwhelming, especially with all the confusing Medicare terms. You’re trying to make intelligent choices for your health and wallet, and everyone seems to have a different opinion.
You’re probably wondering, is Medigap worth it for me? It’s a common question.
Let’s break down what Medicare Supplemental Insurance does together. Then you’ll know if it’s right for you.
Understanding Medicare’s Gaps
First, let’s understand Medigap and why it exists. Then, you can answer, “Do I really need supplemental insurance with Medicare?” It boils down to this one fact.
Original Medicare (Part A and Part B) is good but doesn’t cover all healthcare expenses. Deductibles, copays, and coinsurance are the “gaps” in Medicare coverage, which Medigap covers. So, are Medicare Supplement plans worth it? They are if you want protection from Original Medicare’s out-of-pocket costs.
What Medigap Does
Medigap plans step in to help fill those gaps. These supplemental insurance plans, offered by private insurance companies, are designed to cover some or all of the costs that Original Medicare doesn’t. This makes your healthcare bills more predictable and helps you avoid financial surprises.
That’s what Medigap coverage is used for. It helps you pay some of the costs that Medicare does not pay, including deductibles, copayments, and coinsurance. Even one of the three cheap Medicare Supplements is better than no coverage.
A great way to better understand what Medigap covers is to look at the following chart. Then, you will know the truth about Medicare supplemental insurance and how it protects you.
The left side of the chart shows the cost gaps in Original Medicare. The columns to the right show how each of the ten standardized Medigap plans covers these gaps.
Get a Free Medicare Supplement Rate Comparison
Is Medigap Worth It? Weighing the Pros and Cons
Now for the big question: is supplemental insurance worth it? The truth is, there’s no single answer that fits everyone.
The best choice depends on your needs and lifestyle. Let’s explore the pros and cons to help you decide.
Advantages of Medigap
- Peace of Mind: Knowing you’re financially protected from unexpected medical costs is invaluable, and that’s what Medigap provides. Imagine facing a sudden hospital stay—without Medigap, you could pay thousands of dollars out-of-pocket.
- Doctor Choice: With Medigap, you can see any doctor or hospital in the US that accepts Original Medicare. Networks do not limit you, so you can stay with trusted healthcare providers.
- Foreign Travel Coverage: Some Medigap plans offer emergency care coverage when traveling abroad, reducing some of the stress of international travel.
Also See: Why Medicare Advantage Plans are Bad.
Drawbacks of Medigap
- Monthly Premiums: Medigap does come with a monthly cost, and the average cost of Medicare Supplement Insurance is going up. Like any insurance, you pay premiums for that peace of mind.
- No Extra Perks: Medigap plans cover the gaps in Original Medicare. They don’t offer the extra perks like dental, vision, or hearing coverage that you might find with some Medicare Advantage plans.
Related Reading: Disadvantages of Medigap Plans.
Making the Decision
Are Medigap plans worth it? Deciding to choose a plan can be challenging. Here’s what to consider:
Your Health
Your health is the most essential factor. Consider your current health and family history. Do you have ongoing health conditions? Are there specific health issues in your family? How likely are you to need more healthcare as you age?
If you anticipate higher healthcare needs, Medigap’s comprehensive coverage and lack of out-of-pocket surprises can make it the better choice. A Medicare Advantage plan may be appealing if you’re very healthy, with potential extra perks and lower upfront costs. Just realize that most Medicare Advantage plans come with many out-of-pocket costs, one of the biggest disadvantages of Medicare Advantage.
Your Financial Situation
Look at your budget. Can you comfortably afford monthly Medigap premiums? Remember, this may mean lower overall healthcare expenses in the long run.
Weigh this against the possibility of higher out-of-pocket costs with Medicare Advantage. Find a balance between upfront costs and peace of mind that suits your finances.
TIP: A high-deductible Medigap plan might be a good option if you’re healthy and looking for ways to save money.
Your Retiree Benefits
Do you have retiree benefits, including health insurance? Often, this is a Medicare Advantage group plan subsidized by your former employer. This can make Medicare Advantage a cost-effective option.
Your Travel Plans
Do you travel often? If so, how will you be covered abroad? Original Medicare usually doesn’t cover expenses outside the U.S., while many Medigap plans provide at least partial coverage for emergencies overseas. This can be a significant advantage if you’re a frequent traveler.
Where You Live
Your location can influence your options. Larger cities typically offer more choices for healthcare providers and Medicare Advantage plans. Rural areas might have fewer choices and higher prices for supplements. In some counties without private Medicare Advantage plans, Medigap becomes essential for managing costs alongside Original Medicare.
When to Sign Up for Medigap
You can buy a Medigap plan whenever it’s convenient for you. However, during your one-time, six-month Medicare Supplement Open Enrollment Period (Medigap OEP), you gain valuable protection for pre-existing conditions.
This period starts when you enroll in Medicare Part B at 65 or older. Waiting to apply when you have a health issue could result in private health insurance companies denying coverage.
Get a Free Medicare Supplement Rate Comparison
Understanding the Cost Difference: Why Medigap Might Seem Pricier
When people compare Medigap Plan F or G premiums with Medicare Advantage HMO or PPO plans, they often experience sticker shock. Although those Medicare Advantage premiums are often smaller, you need to understand where you pay for healthcare with each type of plan.
Think of it this way: with Medigap, you generally pay more upfront through monthly premiums. With Medicare Advantage, you pay more as you use services.
Medicare Advantage often means a copay for each doctor’s visit. However, staying healthy can lead to savings due to lower premiums and added perks like dental or vision. Some Medicare Advantage plans in metro areas offer very low or zero-dollar premiums, making them appear even more budget-friendly.
Medicare Advantage may initially look attractive, but you need to balance those lower premiums against potential costs later. Those copays can add up.
With Medigap, premiums might be higher, but you benefit from low or nonexistent deductibles and coinsurance. This can drastically reduce your out-of-pocket expenses. Is supplemental Medicare insurance a waste of money when it protects you from these costs?
A Medicare Advantage plan might make sense if you’re in good health and rarely see a doctor. However, if you need frequent healthcare, those copays can add up, especially as your need for medical care increases.
Table 1: Understanding When Medigap May Be Worth the Extra Cost
| Circumstance | Is Medigap Worth it? | Why or Why Not |
| Frequent healthcare needs due to chronic illnesses or medical conditions. | Likely yes | Comprehensive coverage will help you budget for medical care better and provide predictable, more consistent out-of-pocket costs. |
| Good health and only need routine checkups. | May not be the best value. | With its lower premiums and extra benefits like dental or vision care, Medicare Advantage could save you money. |
| Retiree benefits through an employer or union contribute towards a group Medicare Advantage Plan. | Likely not, unless it comes with extremely high cost-sharing. | An employer-provided plan often offers considerable cost savings over Medigap. It also includes access to additional coverage, such as dental, hearing, and vision benefits, not available through Original Medicare. |
| Desire to see any doctor or specialist and don’t want to deal with referrals. | Yes | Medigap will likely give you better doctor and specialist options since no network restrictions exist. |
| Love to travel or desire for peace of mind during international travel. | Yes | Original Medicare and Medicare Advantage will not cover medical expenses abroad. Certain Medigap plans, such as Plan G, D, C, F, M, and N, do offer partial emergency coverage while traveling outside the US. |
| Live in a rural or smaller community with limited Medicare Advantage choices. | Likely yes | Medigap often becomes a necessary component for those residing in rural communities with restricted access to private health plan options. It is often your only option. |
| You dislike managed care systems like HMOs and PPOs, even when choosing an Advantage PPO plan. | Yes. | Original Medicare combined with a supplemental Medigap policy gives you maximum control over your healthcare and unlimited choices for your care providers. |
| Have concerns about budgeting for unpredictable or substantial medical expenses in the future. | Yes. | A supplemental plan helps to cover copayments, coinsurance, and deductibles, giving you predictable healthcare costs and reducing uncertainty, especially when you are facing large bills for unexpected illnesses or treatments. |
| You are dual-eligible and qualify for both Medicare and Medicaid, particularly if a full dual plan is available in your area. | Possibly, depending on coverage through your Medicaid program. | Medicare Advantage offers special needs plans that wrap in Medicare and Medicaid into a comprehensive option. Full Dual Special Needs Plans are even better and may remove nearly all cost-sharing for Medicare services, although Medigap plans generally offer you more choice over your providers. |
Find Plans in your area with your ZIP Code
FAQs about is Medigap worth it
FAQ 1: What are the disadvantages of a Medigap plan?
A primary disadvantage is the upfront cost. You pay for peace of mind in advance with those monthly premiums, which are in addition to your Part B premium. Also, while some Medigap plans will cover most expenses after Medicare pays its share, they lack the additional benefits of some Medicare Advantage plans, such as a Part D prescription drug plan, dental, or vision care. You’ll need to purchase those extras separately, adding to your budget.
Even though the upfront costs might seem high, having Medigap provides predictable expenses compared to the unpredictable copays, out-of-network costs, and high maximum limits often associated with Medicare Advantage.
FAQ 2: Why do people choose Medigap over Medicare Advantage?
People appreciate the freedom of choice that comes with Medigap. They can visit any doctor or specialist who accepts Medicare without needing a referral. You can even keep seeing a doctor you’ve had for years. There are no network restrictions to worry about. It eliminates the hassle, especially for those seeking specialized care.
In some counties, especially rural ones, supplemental plans are essential because there aren’t enough private Medicare Advantage plan options, if any.
FAQ 3: Why is a Plan G better than a Medicare Advantage plan?
Claiming that Plan G is always better than Medicare Advantage plans is inaccurate. The ideal plan depends on individual circumstances and healthcare needs. However, Plan G has notable advantages. The most significant? After you meet the Part B deductible, Plan G covers most out-of-pocket costs that Original Medicare doesn’t, with a few exceptions.
This comprehensive coverage offers excellent protection against expensive medical bills. Medicare Advantage, on the other hand, often means facing copays for services, adding an element of financial uncertainty. Although Medicare Advantage plans usually have lower monthly premiums, you’ll face extra costs every time you visit a doctor or have a hospital stay.
FAQ 4: Why would a patient want Medigap insurance?
It comes down to predictable healthcare costs and control over your healthcare choices. With Original Medicare paired with a supplemental insurance policy, you minimize financial risks and the uncertainty that often comes with potential illnesses or accidents. Although Medigap might seem more expensive upfront, consider it an investment in peace of mind. You’ll have a safety net against high healthcare expenses and retain the ability to choose your doctors.
Conclusion
Deciding if Medigap suits you is more complex than comparing monthly premiums. It requires careful consideration of your health, location, and priorities. Is Medicare supplemental insurance worth it? It is if your health is a priority and you can afford it.
Weighing the pros and cons of each plan type is essential. This information will empower you to determine whether a Medigap plan aligns with your healthcare needs and provides the peace of mind you seek.