MedicareWire

Shop and compare Medicare plans nationwide.

Speak to a Licensed Advisor[1]

1-855-266-4865

Mon-Fri: 8:30 a.m. to 8:00 p.m. ET

  • Medicare Advantage
  • Medicare Part D
  • Medigap
  • Special Needs
  • More➲
    • Senior Dental Insurance
    • Best Medicare Plans
    • MedicareWire Blog
      • Latest Posts
      • Medicare Insurance Plans
      • What Does Medicare Cover?
    • Important Resources
    • Frequently Asked Questions
    • Medicare Glossary
Home › Medicare Insurance Plans › Brand New Day vs. 5-Star Kaiser Medicare Advantage in California

Brand New Day vs. 5-Star Kaiser Medicare Advantage in California

October 16, 2020

Brand New Day vs. 5-Star Kaiser Medicare Advantage

Medicare Advantage plans expanded into dozens of new counties for the 2021 plan year. With the expansion in plans also came the news that the Centers for Medicare and Medicaid Services (CMS) increased the maximum out-of-pocket (MOOP) limit from $6,700 to $7,550 per year.

However, several companies, including Brand New Day, a Medicare Advantage prescription health plan available in 16 California counties, are bucking the trend by lowering their MOOP below $1,000.  Conversely, industry-leading Kaiser Medicare Advantage has their MOOP set between $2,900 and $6,700 (rate varies by county and plan).

Want to compare Medicare Advantage Plans in California? Do so here.

Why is a Plan’s MOOP a Big Deal?

One of the most significant features built into Medicare Advantage is the Maximum Out-of-Pocket safeguard. It is basically the safety net designed into private plans to ensure Medicare beneficiaries avoid bankruptcy due to a serious illness or accident. But, let’s face it, the new $7,550 MOOP limit is a bitter pill to swallow for most people with Medicare benefits.

Brand New Day’s $999 MOOP is a welcome sign. In the past, MedicareWire has criticized the Medicare Advantage program for tricking seniors into HMO plans with zero-dollar premiums, only to later discover they can’t afford the health care services they need. However, Brand New Day, a 3.5-star Medicare Advantage plan, is showing their commitment to delivering care at an affordable cost.

A super low MOOP isn’t the only way Brand New Day is getting Kaiser Medicare Advantage plan members to reconsider their options. Many of their copays are lower, too, as shown in this sampling of plan costs in San Diego County.

ServicesKaiserBrand New Day
Primary Care Doctor:$15 co-pay$0 co-pay
Mental Health Specialist (individual):$15 co-pay$10 co-pay
Mental Health Specialist (group):$7 co-pay$10 co-pay
Occupational Therapy Specialist:$30 co-pay$30 co-pay
Emergency Room Care:$90 co-pay$100 co-pay
(waived if admitted within 24 days)(waived if admitted within 24 days)
Ambulance Services:$200 co-pay$125 co-pay
Hospital Inpatient Stay:$285 per day for days 1 through 7$100 per day for days 1 through 4
$0 per day for days 8 through 90$0 per day for days 5 through 90
$0 per day for days 91 and beyond$0 per day for days 91 and beyond
Sample: Kaiser H0524-037 vs. Brand New Day H0838-037. Rates vary by plan and county.

What About Quality of Care?

Are Kaiser’s quality ratings from CMS worth the additional out-of-pocket costs? For 2021 Kaiser achieved 5 stars in all quality measures, save one, “Member Experience with Health Plan”, where Kaiser scored 4 stars.

Brand New Day was given a 1-star score on the same measure, showing the Achilles’ heel of the plan. MedicareWire encourages potential members to consider what a 1-star rating in member experience truly means. Clearly, many members were not satisfied with how the plan treated them when they required health services.

Here’s how CMS scored Brand New Day in all of the top rating categories:

Brand New Day
CMS 5-Star Review Ratings

CMS MeasureStar Rating
2021 Overall Rating☆☆☆☆☆
Staying Healthy: Screenings, Tests, Vaccines☆☆☆☆☆
Managing Chronic (Long Term) Conditions☆☆☆☆☆
Member Experience with Health Plan☆☆☆☆☆
Complaints and Changes in Plans Performance☆☆☆☆☆
Health Plan Customer Service☆☆☆☆☆
Drug Plan Customer Service☆☆☆☆☆
Complaints and Changes in the Drug Plan☆☆☆☆☆
Member Experience with the Drug Plan☆☆☆☆☆
Drug Safety and Accuracy of Drug Pricing☆☆☆☆☆

Who Should Consider a Brand New Day Medicare Advantage Plan?

As soon as Brand New Day fixes their member experience issue, everyone should take a look at these plans based on their value. Until then, healthy seniors will do well on this plan. Likewise, it appears that members with certain chronic conditions do well with a Brand New Day plan.

Where Does Brand New Day Offer Medicare Advantage Plans?

Brand New Day Medicare Advantage Plans are available in the following counties:

  • Fresno County, CA
  • Imperial County, CA
  • Kern County, CA
  • Kings County, CA
  • Los Angeles County, CA
  • Madera County, CA
  • Orange County, CA
  • Riverside County, CA
  • Sacramento County, CA
  • San Bernardino County, CA
  • San Diego County, CA
  • San Francisco County, CA
  • San Joaquin County, CA
  • San Mateo County, CA
  • Santa Clara County, CA
  • Tulare County, CA

More About Brand New Day

Brand New Day offers a number of specialty plans in addition to its standard Medicare plan. In addition to its Medicare only, Medicare and Medi-Cal members, the plan offers specialized programs for those with ongoing medical conditions including Diabetes, Cardiovascular Disease, Dementia, and Mental Illness.

Brand New Day serves those who live in long-term care facilities. The HMO plan’s approach is designed to keep its members healthy and independent. For more information about Brand New Day, visit BNDHMO.com or call (866) 255-4795.

Article by David Bynon / Medicare Insurance Plans / medicare advantage plans

Is CMS Biased in Favor of Medicare Advantage?

While studying Medicare & You 2021: The official U.S. government Medicare handbook to look for changes coming in the new year (which you can download here), the MedicareWire staff began noticing language and diagrams that it felt would bias readers. In fact, once you start looking for it, you … [Read More...]

2021 Medicare Open Enrollment: A Guide to Dates, Costs and Eligibility

Everything you need to know about Medicare's Annual Election Period (AEP) dates, costs, eligibility, and opportunities to change your Medicare insurance coverage this Fall. What’s in this 2021 Medicare AEP guide? When is Medicare Open Enrollment for 2021 Coverage? How to Enroll in … [Read More...]

Does Medicare Cover Physical Therapy After An Accident or Surgery?

Does Medicare Cover Physical Therapy? If you’re covered by Medicare and have an illness or injury that requires physical therapy, you may wonder, “what does Medicare cover?” More specifically, you’ll likely want to know does Medicare cover physical therapy? In this article, we will look at … [Read More...]

Does Medicare Cover Eye Exams for Seniors?

Does Medicare Cover Eye Exams? With Original Medicare, you have coverage for all of the routine checkups and preventative care you need. But what about your eyes? If you are wondering if your medicare benefits cover visits to the eye doctor, you might be surprised by the answer: Original … [Read More...]

Does Medicare Cover Hearing Aids for Seniors Who Need Hearing Assistance?

Does Medicare Cover Hearing Aids? If you're someone who's hard of hearing and in need of financial assistance, you've probably asked yourself this. After all, hearing aids can be expensive. They require the devices themselves, costly batteries, proper fitment, and it helps to have them … [Read More...]

More Posts from this Category

Related Topics

[1] Licensed Sales Agent

Licensed sales agent (“advisor”) services are provided by HealthPlanOne, LLC, MedicareWire’s trusted partner. Read our full sales agent disclosure.

[2] Trademark Notice

MedicareWire uses legal U.S. trademarks to identify and describe Medicare and other insurance products for shoppers. See our full trademark use disclosure.

About MedicareWire

  • About
  • Contact
  • Connect with Us!
  • Privacy
  • Disclosure
  • Medicare Supplement Reviews

Copyright © 2021 MedicareWire.com - All Rights Reserved

Who is MedicareWire?
David Bynon
Chief Petty Officer David Bynon re-enlisting 15 September 2001.

Hello, my name is David Bynon.

I founded MedicareWire in 2011 after retiring from the Navy. I’ve made helping people like you my full-time retirement profession.

My goal is to help you see all the rates offered by insurance companies that sell Medigap policies in your area.

I am not an insurance agent.

My job is to make sure that you have the information you need to be comfortable with your plan decision. When it comes to choosing a Medigap plan, I want you to be able to see all rates and carriers before speaking with an agent.

To provide you with this free service, I need to ask you to provide your age, gender, zip code, and email address. I promise to keep your information secure. You can count on me not to share, sell, or otherwise divulge your information to anyone.

Yours in Better Medicare.

David Bynon

Medigap Quotes by Email: Compare and Save!


Complete this form and MedicareWire will send you a complete rate analysis on Medigap plans in your area. This is a free service with no obligations.

Answers to the following questions will allow us to get accurate information for you. These are some of the same questions you will be asked when you apply for insurance. We will not sell, provide, or otherwise disclose the information you provide to anyone.

  • This field is for validation purposes and should be left unchanged.